Exploring the Social Imagination

Wednesday, April 14, 2021

Pulling the Wool over your Eyes in the Social Imagination...

 

Health does not come by injection...so why pull the wool? 

This commentary comes from a 'fellow social media blogger', Christian Elliot. Now, I don't know him personally but from one blogger to another what he writes about is close to my imagination. So, here's a share... from one to another interested in truth.

The only industry in the world that bears no liability for injuries or deaths resulting from their products, are vaccine makers.

First established in 1986 with the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act, and reinforced by the PREP Act, vaccine makers cannot be sued, even if they are shown to be negligent.The covid-vaccine makers are allowed to create a one-size-fits-all product, with no testing on sub-populations (i.e. people with specific health conditions), and yet they are unwilling to accept any responsibility for any adverse events or deaths their products cause.

If a company is not willing to stand behind their product as safe, especially one they rushed to market and skipped animal trials on, I am not willing to take a chance on their product. No liability. No trust.

The checkered past of a few vaccine companies. The four major companies who are making these covid vaccines are/have either:

  1. Never brought a vaccine to market before covid (Moderna and Johnson & Johnson).
  2. Are serial felons (Pfizer, and Astra Zeneca).
  3. Are both (Johnson & Johnson).
Moderna had been trying to "Modernize our RNA" (thus the company name)--for years, but had never successfully brought ANY product to market--how nice for them to get a major cash infusion from the government to keep trying.

In fact, all major vaccine makers (save Moderna) have paid out tens of billions of dollars in damages for other products they brought to market when they knew those products would cause injuries and death--see Vioxx, Bextra, Celebrex, Thalidomide, and Opioids as a few examples.

If drug companies willfully choose to put harmful products in the market, when they can be sued, why would we trust any product where they have NO liability?

In case it hasn't sunk in, let me reiterate...3 of the 4 covid vaccine makers have been sued for products they brought to market even though they knew injuries and deaths would result.

Given the free pass from liability, and the checkered past of these companies, why would we assume that all their vaccines are safe and made completely above board?

There have been many attempts to make viral vaccines in the past that ended in utter failure, which is why we did not have a coronavirus vaccine in 2020.

In the 1960's, scientists attempted to make an RSV (Respiratory Syncytial Virus) vaccine for infants.  that study, they skipped animal trials because they weren't necessary back then. In the end, the vaccinated infants got much sicker than the unvaccinated infants when exposed to the virus in nature, with 80% of the vaccinated infants requiring hospitalization and two of them died.

After 2000, scientists made many attempts to create coronavirus vaccines. For the past 20 years, all ended in failure because the animals in the clinical trials got very sick and many died, just like the children in the 1960's.

The typical pattern in such studies found that children and animals produced beautiful antibody responses after being vaccinated. However, the problem came when the children and animals were exposed to the wild version of the virus.

When that happened, an unexplained phenomenon called Antibody Dependent Enhancement (ADE) also known as Vaccine Enhanced Disease (VED) occurred where the immune system produced a "cytokine storm" (i.e. overwhelmingly attacked the body), and the children/animals died.

Here's the lingering issue...The vaccine makers have no data to suggest their rushed vaccines have overcome that problem. In other words, never before has any attempt to make a coronavirus vaccine been successful, nor has the gene-therapy technology that is mRNA "vaccines" been safely brought to market, but hey, since they had billions of dollars in government funding, I'm sure they figured that out.

When vaccine makers submitted their papers to the FDA for the Emergency Use Authorization (Note: An EUA is not the same as a full FDA approval), among the many "Data Gaps" they reported was that they have nothing in their trials to suggest they overcame that pesky problem of Vaccine Enhanced Disease.

They simply don't know--i.e. they have no idea if the vaccines they've made will also produce the same cytokine storm (and deaths) as previous attempts at such products.

In case you think I'm making this up, or want to see the actual documents sent to the FDA by Pfizer and Moderna for their Emergency Use Authorization, you can check out this, or this respectively. The data gaps can be found starting with page 46 and 48 respectively.

For now let's turn our eyes to the raw data the vaccine makers used to submit for emergency use authorization.

Would you like to see the raw data that produced the "90% and 95% effective" claims touted in the news? Me too...But they won't let us see that data. There were “3,410 total cases of suspected, but unconfirmed covid-19 in the overall study population, 1,594 occurred in the vaccine group vs. 1,816 in the placebo group.”

Did they fail to do science in their scientific study by not verifying a major variable?Could they not test those "suspected but unconfirmed" cases to find out if they had covid? Apparently not.Why not test all 3,410 participants for the sake of accuracy? Can we only guess they didn't test because it would mess up their "90-95% effective" claims?

Where's the FDA? Would it not be prudent for the FDA, to expect (demand) that the vaccine makers test people who have "covid-like symptoms," and release their raw data so outside, third-parties could examine how the manufacturers justified the numbers?

Why did the FDA not require that? Isn't that the entire purpose of the FDA anyway? Good question. Obviously, with products that have only been on the market a few months, we have no long-term safety data. In other words, we have no idea what this product will do in the body months or years from now--for ANY population.

Given all the risks above (risks that ALL pharmaceutical products have), would it not be prudent to wait to see if the worst-case scenarios have indeed been avoided? Would it not make sense to want to fill those pesky "data gaps" before we try to give this to every man, woman, and child on the planet?

Moreover, those who are planning to take or have taken the vaccine don't know is that because these products are still in clinical trials, anyone who gets the shot is now part of the clinical trial. They are part of the experiment.

Those (like me) who do not take it, are part of the control group.Time will tell how this experiment works out. But, you may be asking, if the vaccines are causing harm, wouldn't we be seeing that all over the news? Surely, the FDA would step in and pause the distribution?

 Aren't these vaccines supposed to be what we've been waiting for to "go back to normal"?  Why do you think we're getting all these conflicting messages about needing to practice social distancing and wear masks AFTER we get a vaccine?

The reason is because these vaccines were never designed to stop transmission OR infection.If you don't believe me, I refer you again to the papers submitted to the FDA I linked to above. The primary endpoint (what the vaccines are meant to accomplish) is to lower your symptoms. Sounds like just about every other drug on the market right? That's it...lowering your symptoms is the big payoff we've been waiting for.

Does that seem completely pointless to anyone but me?

  1. It can't stop us from spreading the virus.
  2. It can't stop the virus from infecting us once we have it.
  3. To get the vaccine is to accept all the risk of these experimental products and the best it might do is lower symptoms?

If we're worried about asymptomatic spreaders, would the vaccine not make it more likely that we are creating asymptomatic spread? If it indeed reduces symptoms, anyone who gets it might not even know they are sick and thus they are more likely to spread the virus, right?

 For what it's worth, I've heard many people say the side effects of the vaccine (especially the second dose) are worse than catching covid. Guess what? You get vaccinated and you still catch covid.

According to the CDC's own numbers, covid has a 99.74% survival rate. Why would I take a risk on a product, that doesn't stop infection or transmission, to help me overcome a cold that has a .26% chance of killing me--actually in my age range is has about a .1% chance of killing me (and .01% chance of killing my kids), but let's not split hairs here...

What has happened to the scientific method of always challenging our assumptions? What happened to lively debate in this country, or at least in Western society? Why did anyone who disagrees with the WHO, or the CDC get censored so heavily?

Is the science of public health a religion now, or is science supposed to be about debate? If someone says "the science is settled" that's how I know I'm dealing with someone who is closed minded.

 By definition science (especially biological science) is never settled. If it was, it would be dogma, not science. If lockdowns work, I want to do my part and stay home. If masks work, I want to wear them.

 If social distancing is effective, I want to comply. But, if there is evidence they don't (masks for example), I want to hear that evidence too. If highly-credentialed scientists have different opinions, I want to know what they think. Don't you?

I want a chance to hear their arguments and make up my own mind. I don't think I'm the smartest person in the world, but I think I can think. I for one think there's a lot more that we have in common than what separates us.

We all want to live in a world of freedom. We all want to do our part to help others and to live well. We all want the right to express our opinions without fearing we'll be censored or viciously attacked. We all deserve to have the access to the facts so we can make informed decisions.

 

By Christian Elliot ~

https://www.deconstructingconventional.com/post/18-reason-i-won-t-be-getting-a-covid-vaccine?

 

 

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Science is only what men make of it in the Social Imagination...

 


Why So Much Science is Wrong, False, Puffed "up", or Misleading?

Written in 2020 by Joachim Book...

In a year where scientists seemed to have gotten everything wrong, a book attempting to explain why is bizarrely relevant. Of course, science was in deep trouble long before the pandemic began and Stuart Ritchie’s excellent Science Fictions: How Fraud, Bias, Negligence, and Hype Undermine the Search for Truth had been long in the making. Much welcomed, nonetheless, and very important.  

For a contrarian like me, reading Ritchie is good for my mental sanity – but bad for my intellectual integrity. It fuels my priors that a lot of people, even experts, delude themselves into thinking they know things they actually don’t. Fantastic scientific results, either the kind blasted across headlines or those which gradually make it into public awareness, are often so poorly made that the results don’t hold up; they don’t capture anything real about the world. The book is a wake-up call for a scientific establishment often too blinded by its own erudite proclamations. 

Filled with examples and accessible explanations, Ritchie expertly leads the reader on a journey through science’s many troubles. He categorizes them by the four subtitles of the book: fraud, bias, negligence, and hype. Together, they all undermine the search for truth that is science’s raison d’être. It’s not that scientists willfully lie, cheat, or deceive – even though that happens uncomfortably often, even in the best of journals – but that poorly designed experiments, underpowered studies, spreadsheet errors or intentionally or unintentionally manipulated p-values yield results that are too good to be true.

Since academics’ careers depend on publishing novel, fascinating and significant results, most of them don’t look a gift horse in the mouth. If the statistical software says “significant,” they confidently write up the study and persuasively argue their amazing case before a top-ranked journal, its editors, and the slacking peers in the field who are supposed to police their mistakes.  

Ritchie isn’t some crackpot science denier or conspiracy theorist working out of his mom’s basement; he’s a celebrated psychologist at King’s College London with lots of experience in debunking poorly-made research, particularly in his own field of psychology. For the last decade or more, this discipline has been the unfortunate poster child for the “Replication Crisis,” the discovery that – to use Stanford’s John Ioannidis’ well-known article title – “Most Published Research Findings Are False.”

Take the example of former Cornell psychology professor Daryl Bem and his infamous “psychic pornography” experiment that opens Ritchie’s book. On screens, a thousand undergraduates were shown two curtains, only one of which hid an image that the students were supposed to find. The choice was a coin toss, as they had no other information to go on. As expected, for most kinds of images they picked the right curtain about 50% of the time. But – and here was Bem’s claim to fame – when pornographic images hid behind the curtails, students choose the right one 53% of the time, enough to pass for statistical significance in his sample. The road for top-ranked publication was wide open. 

When the article came out after passing peer review, the world was stunned to learn that undergrads could see the future – at least when images of a sexual nature were involved. Proven by science, certified by The Scientific Method™, the psychology world was thrown into chaos. The study was done properly, passed peer review, and published in a top field journal, with the same method that underlies all the other well-known results in the field. Still, the result was totally bonkers. What had gone wrong?

Or take the don of behavioral economics, Daniel Kahneman, whose many quirky experiments convinced an entire economics profession of individual irrationality and ultimately earned him the Nobel Prize. The psychological literature on so-called ‘priming,’ part of which is used by behavioral economists, suggested that tiny changes in settings can produce remarkably large impacts in behavior. For instance, subtly reminding people of money – through symbols or the clicking noise of coins – makes them behave more individualistically and less caring of others. “Disbelief is not an option,” wrote Kahneman in his famous best-seller Thinking, Fast and Slow, “you have no choice but to accept that the major conclusions of these [priming] studies are true.”

Beginning in the 2010s, psychologists tried to replicate these famous results and more. When tried elsewhere, with other students, better equipment, or larger samples – or sometimes with the exact same data – the same results wouldn’t emerge. How odd. Lab teams tried to replicate many established findings, coming up way short: “The replication crisis seems,” writes Ritchie, “with a snap of its fingers, to have wiped about half of all psychology research off the map.” There was something structurally wrong in the way that psychology found and displayed knowledge. Some research. 

Chance encounters, like Bem’s supernatural students, sometimes make it through into published literature. More disheartening are the actual instances of fraud, where scientists forge their data, manipulate them, or simply make them up out of thin air. Ritchie’s many stories can make you lose faith in many a scientific establishment: scientists inventing spreadsheets (caught only because humans are very bad at creating true randomness), tilting microscope pictures sideways, reusing the same numbers while pretending they were another data set.  

While everyone agrees that fraud is a problem, and the challenge is to prevent it or detect it before it causes too much damage, the other flaws (bias, negligence, and hype) are more widespread – and more damaging because of it. They operate in more subtle ways, out of sight and impossible for outsiders to adjust to. Take the file-drawer problem, where negative results are stuffed away while positive results – most commonly obtained by chance, like Bem’s psychic experiment – are sent off for publication, giving a false impression of the state of the world, both in the literature and for the wider public. 

What’s fascinating in Ritchie’s book are the discussions of many studies, claims, and experiments with which even non-experts are familiar. Well-referenced and comprehensively cited, Ritchie reports huge problems with the following hyped stories: 

  • Larger plates make you eat more.
  • Going to the supermarket hungry makes you buy more calories.
  • Eggs cause cardiovascular disease.
  • In messy or dirty environments people display more racial stereotypes. 
  • Power posing (manspreading or placing your hands aggressively on your hips) creates a psychological and hormonal boost that correlates with higher risk tolerance and better life outcomes.
  • Philip Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison Experiment and the inhuman cruelty by people in authority ( debunked perhaps most effectively by Gina Perry’s many in-depth writings on famous psychology experiments). 
  • Sleeping less than six hours a night “demolishes your immune system [,] doubling your risk of cancer,” as the best-selling book Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker claimed. 

All wrong. Every one of these much-publicized and discussed claims include at least one of the following: misleading conclusions not warranted by the research itself; fabricated data; data manhandled to pass significance tests; incompetent experimental designs; or experiments that wouldn’t replicate when tried by other scientists. Taking them apart for a non-expert audience is where Ritchie really shines. 

We’re not surprised that news headlines misunderstand, exaggerate, or fail to report nuance, but Ritchie shows that even the published literature that supports these claims have detrimental flaws, undermining their results. As far as the rest of the world is concerned, that hasn’t mattered much. For these claims, the cat was out of the bag. Many of their results have reached the nonscientific public and entered “common knowledge.” I have personally had three different people, on different occasions, inform me about the dangers of eating eggs – two of them in doctoral programs at some of the most prestigious universities in the world. Being sharp and being right are two very different things. 

That makes me think that Hype is the worst of science’s many sins as trigger-happy researchers (or even admired institutions like NASA) write puffy press releases on some revolutionary claim that turns out to be fraudulent, negligent, poorly made, underpowered or just flat-out unsupported by its own research. 

Some of these eerie stories of mistaken research have serious outcomes in the real world: examples include Reinhart and Rogoff’s government debt-inhibits-growth error, Paolo Macchiarini’s fraudulent endeavors operating on patients at Karolinska Institute, or the wholly made-up research that suggested the combined measles, mumps and rubella vaccine caused autism. Even smaller and comparatively more innocent errors like p-hacking, shifting outcome goalposts, or underpowered studies with much-too-large effects hurt science and make the world a worse place, as doctors and policy-makers use them in decision-making.  

At one point in the Bias chapter, Ritchie himself loses hope, pondering how to overcome all these statistical and human-made failures to produce accurate knowledge about the world: “My response is that I have no idea,” he writes. 

Somehow he still ends on a slightly more positive note. The last two chapters provide many hopeful suggestions for how science can improve on its many challenges: we can fund research differently; journals can pre-commit to publication if the study design is good enough, publishing more negative results; we can pre-register methods such that researchers can’t shift the target variable mid-study; we can withhold some grant money until publication, to financially punish researchers that file-drawer their unsuccessful results.  

More refreshingly is computer technology and the rampant transparency it allows. Entire datasets can be put online and codes can be analyzed line-by-line by many more than the handful of peer reviewers and editors that (should) usually do so. Besides, the reason we unearthed so many fraudsters in the first place was by using clever algorithms that found inconsistencies in the statistical outputs of reported results. 

Ritchie warns against the nihilism of becoming “suspicious of any and all new results, given our knowledge that the stream of scientific progress is far from pure.” A healthy dose of skepticism is good – throwing the baby out with any polluted bathwater isn’t. Science is “one of humanity’s proudest achievements,” he proclaims, and simply because a lot of it is wrong, false, puffed, or misleading, it doesn’t mean that it never correctly identified anything important. On the contrary. 

While I see myself falling into precisely the trap Ritchie fears – that people will misuse his book to deny even well-established scientific results – he worries more about the opposite problem. Correctly so: People, especially in the West, place an extraordinarily high trust in scientists – reaching over 90% in some countries. In the U.K., for instance, the population seems to have grown more trusting of science and its results over time. 

The book, while scary and disheartening, is truth-seeking and ultimately optimistic. Ritchie doesn’t come to bury science; he comes to fix it. “The ideals of the scientific process aren’t the problem,” he writes on the last page, “the problem is the betrayal of those ideals by the way we do research in practice.”

 

*Stuart James Ritchie is a Scottish psychologist and science communicator known for his research in human intelligence. He has served as a lecturer at the Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience at King’s College London since the summer of 2018. He was previously active in researching intelligence as a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Edinburgh.

 

Blogger's comment ~ In the past, I have blogged numerous times about social reality being experienced as agreement reality; in fact, stating that is all there is in an information reality "agreement" in the social imagination. In the meaning, that is where any of us/all of us exist and no place else. Charles H. Cooley, my favorite American Sociologist said that everything happens in the locus of your mind. And, he was right. 

In the above article, it is advocated that a healthy dose of skepticism is good – throwing the baby out with any polluted bathwater isn’t. Science is “one of humanity’s proudest achievements,”as Stuart J. Ritchie proclaims and simply because a lot of it is wrong, false, puffed "up", or misleading; but, that doesn’t mean it never correctly identified anything important. 

There is the key... "doesn't mean it ...(science) never correctly identified anything important". That phrase is the key to understanding that science is only what men make of it... its only what men agree on.... then and only then can something be 'identified' as important.

Indeed, that is important because its the only way we identify with everything we encounter as 'information' including ourselves. If we can't agree on what something is or is not... we essentially don't or can't identify with it... at least not on any deeper level of meaning unless someone else can/can't identify with whatever it is either. If they can, their ability to identify as well as their inability to identify, will help someone else and if they neither one can... at least they can commiserate that they can't.

You see, the social imagination of any and all human groups is a culturally shaped social imagination which means that there is nothing anyone can't agree on even if they agree to disagree. But, anyone or anything outside the boundaries of 'our' social imagination, the one we own as ours, will more than likely never agree on the same things...until they find a way to identify with it in their culturally shaped social imagination. But, that's only if they want to.

 

ONLINE ~ https://www.aier.org/article/why-so-much-science-is-wrong-false-puffed-or-misleading/?fbclid=IwAR294FFKLaQXIeoVzBR3i3oKL3MIo40rMI9F31450SVhyDVbKMWrh52yPak

Wednesday, March 17, 2021

Herd Mentality Vs. Herd Immunity in the Social Imagination...


We previously posted on Herd mentality. Let's review that:
Herd mentality (also known as mob mentality) describes a behavior in which people act the same way or adopt similar behaviors as the people around them — often ignoring their own feelings in the process. Think of a sheep blindly following the flock no matter where they go just because that’s what the herd is doing. And this isn’t just pseudoscience: There have been peer-reviewed psychological studies conducted on the subject.


In 2008, Professor Jens Krause and Dr. John Dyer of Leeds University conducted an experiment where groups of subjects were told to walk in a random path inside of a big hall while not communicating with the other subjects. However, the researchers told a few of the subjects exactly where they should walk.

Guess what happened? They discovered that the people who were told exactly where to walk started being followed by the subjects walking “randomly.” Were told exactly where to walk... Mmm!

From Professor Krause: We’ve all been in situations where we get swept along by the crowd. But what’s interesting about this research is that our participants ended up making a consensus decision despite the fact that they weren’t allowed to talk or gesture to one another. In most cases the participants didn’t realize they were being led by others. Oh wow!
 
Now, is that the same kind of social experience in context of Herd immunity?  Interesting question, isn't it?  What is Herd immunity? We read that Herd immunity occurs when enough people become immune to a disease to make its spread unlikely. As a result, the entire community is protected, even those who are not themselves immune. Herd immunity is usually achieved through vaccination, but it can also occur through natural infection.

Its that last part of the above sentence that we want to pay attention to... "occur through natural infection". That means it passes from one to another naturally. Just as it appears to be with Herd mentality, right?  If we are talking about information then yes. And, on this blog, we are always talking about information reality in the social imagination. 
 
So how could the two be similar in terms of information reality. Again, Herd mentality is about the exchange of information. It happens when one or a couple members of a group behave in a way that attracts others to join in. Herd immunity does the same. How? 
 
It happens in this way. Herd immunity through the 'natural' exchange of information occurs naturally just as it is with Herd mentality. Now, you might think that all Herd mentality is bad but it can be good and bad. Herd immunity is also both good and bad. 
 
Its good because it leads to immunity and bad because through natural infection 'dissemination' of viral information (as it is when a message/meme has 'gone viral') someone can lose rather than gain in that process. In saying that, we realize the same thing can happen in the Herd mentality processing of information. 
 
Though some are walking the right way, that 'right' information can be rejected in order to walk the way everyone else is... just because, it seems that its more likely to be the right way or the better way as in faster or the popular way. Again, you might be wondering how is that like Herd immunity? 
 
Herd immunity doesn't pay attention to the 'right way' either as much as it pays attention to the fastest way possible to circulate what it thinks is 'right' information. This is why, Herd immunity could be argued or could be preferable at least in terms of getting results quicker than long time studies done or research conducted to find a solution. 
 
Herd mentality could be understood in the same way; however, it should not be paid attention to unless its reason for not walking the right way gets results that are better/faster than if the right way was walked all along. Now, that sounds like loopy... Well, Herd immunity is like that too. But, if we consider that any 'right' way to be the fast track, then what is the 'well thought out' slow process of scientific study/research necessary for. Aren't we seeing that now?

Where is the sense in either of these herds; especially, when you hear, "Well, everyone is doing it or going that way... aren't you going to"? Or, "Look, they are doing it, so, I guess we should go along to at least to get along, right"? Or, "I don't want to appear anti something...". Besides, "sooner or later, everyone will be doing it". 
 
Which path are we on/you on? And, who wants to find out by trial and error, right? Interestingly, both "herds" end up in the same predicament in the social imagination. Why/How? No one is outside of either... its all inclusive! 
 
Ironically, most people think that they have a choice or the ability to choose their own way to go; and, no one can say if its the right way or the wrong way... lest they be called a negative charged director; that's jargon for bully. 
 
Whatever... but then again, everyone is in a herd of some kind and if your herd is in charge your herd will attempt to herd the rest. And, every herd has a bull or two.




*scroll down to the next topic and find out what science really is...