Exploring the Social Imagination

Wednesday, March 10, 2021

Imagining an Absolute Source of all Information in the Social Imagination...

 


In a fallen ‘entropic’ world, the social reality is an information reality experience akin to a live streaming event comparable to the game of telephone. The farther from the source, the more scrambled the message.
Yet, even in such a game, we imagine that there was and remains an absolute source or established point of departure that generated what we assume to be useful information since it was circulated … and so, we tend to trust that relayed information even if we cannot see or have a firsthand in-person experience with its source.

Scientists as well as philosophers have been searching for the source of all information. The problem with ‘scientists/philosophers’ is that they fail to recognize that they exist inside the information reality; which is a social agreement reality. It’s the only reality; because, any reality that is observable depends on what two or more people can agree on in the social imagination.

A single person may have all information but if there is no one to agree on what is ‘real’ in the experience of it… then there is no social reality. And, if there is no social reality, then what ‘reality’ is there?

The process of agreement reality can be compared to the collapse of a wave function. Once it is observed (information presented in the moment of observation) it collapses due to being observed. Yet, the truth of that collapse (as an event witnessed) … it must be recognized by more than one (agreed on) in order that its collapse is a real experience.

In quantum mechanics, wave function collapse occurs when a wave function, initially in a superposition of several eigenstates, reduces to a single eigenstate due to interaction with the external world. This is irreversible.

In the world's most famous thought experiment, physicist Erwin Schrödinger described how a cat in a box could be in an uncertain predicament. The peculiar rules of quantum theory meant that it could be both dead and alive, until the box was opened and the cat's state measured.

Without the ability to have and arrive at agreement through shared information which is experience due to interaction with the external world (including the necessary social actors in that world), we would exist in an uncertain predicament.

However, even in saying that, doesn’t mean that what we agree on is really and truly real. Its only as real as we agree on it as being real to us as it was with the cat.

So, in fact, understanding this… shows us how information works for us and against us; and, how disinformation is created from previously agreed on information received through shared experience. Disinformation works to undermine anything that we can agree on as the truth of what is being experienced as real.

When you really consider that on a deep level, within the frame of what we call science, you understand that science is a means for arriving at agreement and nothing more. Its always up to change as agreement changes. Science in its most basic definition is an intellectual and practical activity which relies on agreement in the social imagination. 

Sure, there is a 'process' to what we call science; but, the process does not and cannot move forward if there is no mutual agreement. Many theories remain as such for that very reason.  And, yet... theories also require agreement to be referred to as theories and remain on the theoretical stage.

Science and its scientists are social creatures, living in a social agreement reality. This is dependent on social dynamics of the two or more or group. Which means that over time, as with the game of telephone, the social experience of shared information can be agreed upon differently. There is no concrete evidence existing outside of human observation; what the eye sees and interprets is one thing but that interpretation among many eyes needs agreement to be seen as 'truly' something. 

Charles Darwin, was a social creature like you/me, who wasn't a very good scholar but rather a tag along. In such social context, he was window dressing for his contemporaries. Yes, he was/is attributed to being the 'father of evolution' but when it came to the human eye, he said it was beyond the sphere of his view of evolution. Darwin himself confessed that it was "absurd" to propose that the human eye evolved through spontaneous mutation and natural selection.

In a recent paper, a Darwinian scientist with the help another researcher, were determined to prove the human eye did in fact evolve. So, they looked at slides and declared that they found the molecular fingerprint necessary. They determined this fingerprint to exist in the cells of a worm's brain that for them was quite similar to the human molecular fingerprint (coding of cells) of humans.

This scientist and assistant researcher agree that when this molecular activity in the cells of the worm brain were observed– it was clear to them that these cells shared a molecular fingerprint with humans. This was concrete evidence for them that there is common evolutionary origin. So, two people agreed, it was 'clear' to them. Sounds Darwinian in that they were window dressing. 

What is window dressing? Darwin drew from Baconian principles (build knowledge from the ground up/from nothing) which allows the freedom to accumulate wholesale facts without any preconceived idea as to what they might imply. This scientific 'art' is also known as hpothetico-deductive method.

Darwin was an excellent practitioner of the hypothetico–deductive method. Such claims are little more than “window dressing.” Darwin was seeking to allay the concerns of his contemporaries, whether philosophers or other possible critics, who would surely find his theory of natural selection hard to take and would be prompt to denounce it as a prejudicial abstraction without empirical foundation. So, if you dress up the science it sounds more believable. 

Hypothetical-deductive reasoning involves starting with a general theory of all possible factors that might affect an outcome and forming a hypothesis; then deductions are made from that hypothesis to predict what might happen in an experiment. Now, some call that evidence based... but I call it a vast social imagination...which is only true in agreement and that does not make it absolutely true.

Ok, so is there any way to know what is what as in true and how it came to be? Some look to math for that answer. Now, you may think that math doesn’t change because mathematics deals with the logic of shape, quantity and arrangement. However, math arose out of basic needs and or the basic wants of a society. The more complex a society, the more complex the mathematical needs are.

Mathematics also is dependent upon the social agreement reality in the social imagination. You may argue that 2+2=4. It always has and will. But the social agreement that we stand by (at least for now) is still in agreement that that equation is more true in our social experience of it than it is not true.

So, what is really real? Only that which we agree on and keep agreeing on until something else or some other information changes our social experience of agreement reality. Where could such information come from? The source of all information... of course. Which is? Only God knows and He does.

 

 

 

*online source ~  https://www.pnas.org/content/106/Supplement_1/10033

Friday, February 19, 2021

The Mindlessness of the Unprincipled Social Imagination...


All societies, those that are recognized as a 'society', are based on stable social organization; the kind that works for the majority in the place where they are. Rather than disorganized to the point of chaos and collapse in the place where they are. 

Such stability and social organization needs ideal types in the social imagination. Quite often ideal types are put in place (allowed) by all the participating people as they suit the common good. Most often ideal types are charismatic, heroic and self-determined rather than not. They usually represent what most want to or should aspire to.

Now, many argue that perspective is out of date. Today, many argue that the rich or positioned elite create ideal types and sell them up for others to follow but that's not really true. The top cannot be effective unless the bottom goes along with it... either by force or by mutual agreement according to what is obvious even for the uneducated peasant. 

Sure, you can say or 'feel' that the top always wins because the bottom is ignorant or afraid; but an argument such as that is mistakenly presumed. Why or how? There is a natural order to things.

In sociology, that natural order of things including ideal types is based on the social dynamics of a group which are the necessary 'give and take' found in social interaction. They play the greatest role in any functioning society. Such dynamics exists within all groups, races, religions, and cultures... social actors that are naturally inclined to be either a charismatic dominant or subordinate dull type. Such social dynamics exist in all creatures great and small and serve a purpose... that of sustainability of the group in the place where they are. 

Out of social dynamics, the ideal type arises when needed to maintain stability and sustainability. If we consider evolution to be actual, then ideal types arise naturally among all biological evolving creatures and are stabilized or embedded into the evolving social structure because they serve a purpose which is for stable society and its continued growth. 

You can argue that not all people will agree with that sociological perspective. Since, they themselves may not find themselves or accept that they are either dominant or subordinate or respect ideal types put in place by the group.  In context of social pitfalls, those self excluding social actors were often considered deviant and treated as such by all other participating actors who did not self exclude.

Nonetheless, to better or fully understand the argument for stable society based on social dynamics and ideal types pitted against the mindless unprincipled individual social actor, we can and should look at sexual orientation. For example, recognized gender and its role for stable society. Some think gender is fluid. But, is that biologically true or even scientifically provable?

To arrive at what can be proved let's first consider what is gender fluidity and thus consider the arguments put forward by Michel Foucault. As a social constructionist, Foucault assumed that all of society is socially constructed and that includes sexual orientation.. in the social imagination.

While that might be true, even the social imagination needs stabilization perimeters... lest it falls into a state of mindless chaos and or mental social psychosis. Foucault, just did not seem to fully grasp that.

In Foucault's day, financial disparity was everywhere but that is still true today. Its not due to the bourgeoisie inasmuch as its a problem of rejecting foundational truths of social dynamics. For instance, Foucault wrote about the rise of the bourgeoisie and how they used/use their power dynamic to control society. I am not saying that is not true but it does serve a purpose.

Foucault wrote that there was indeed an effort by the bourgeoisie to control sexuality and how people talked about sexuality so that they could control all of society. 

He said that the bourgeoisie used 'science' to control people's sexual behavior and or preferences. They (the bourgeoisie) said things like, only a biological man and woman can reproduce. This so-called insight led Foucault to spend some time examining knowledge and power. 

Well, we can get into all kinds of arguments about what is power and what is knowledge and what is science. Just read my previous blog about science and the comments left below. The irony, in my view, regarding Foucault, is that the same 'logic' he used can be applied to the proletariat if they were in power.  

Let's go back to social dynamics of a stable society. Ideal types or just social norms exist and are accepted because they work positively in the place where they are. That means, from a bird's eye view, if being a gendered man by nature and a gendered woman by nature create more people naturally for the good of society, to build up society, creating a civilization in a place regardless of the good, bad and ugly, then that will be the norm as that is what works best for a group of people in the place where they are.

To Foucault, sexuality must be understood as a bourgeoisie invention that ensures dominance. Really? I guess so as many reprobates (unprincipled people led into corruption rather than sound doctrine) even today, still believe its purpose is to maintain power. But, again what is power in context of stable society especially in context of reproduction. If that wielded power is to ensure reproduction, then it is a good for society and most participating social actors will engage in that seeing for themselves the good in sexual reproduction and family roles that naturally flow from it. 

Now, if you still are not convinced that  'power' can be justified in that its use in society can create stability for the good of the many in society... then, let's consider the alternative being put forward by the reprobates. For the record, a reprobate is a mindless unprincipled person sadly dysfunctional within a framework of stable society. This mindless unprincipled person is bent on the corruption of the given norm or current shape of an existing stable society. 

The reprobate type is usually an isolated as in excluded individual (they can be either dominant or subordinate and usually the later) who thinks that his/her feelings matter more than what natures deems as truth. They fall out of either dynamic as they deviate from the norm of society at large.

So, let's start there. What if all of society was based on 'feelings' and not biology which is a science? If you recognize that biology is a science and that there are plenty of truths in biology, then you should have nothing to do with feelings. Oddly, Foucault aimed at suggesting that feelings have the biggest role in social constructs rather than biology, reason and or logic. If that is true, then he should not have had a problem with the bourgeoisie; after all, they have feelings too outside of logic and reason. 

Foucault should have been able to recognize the role of the bourgeoisie in stable society, even if they were themselves yet reprobate behind closed doors (many were and are), was necessary as long as they were/are promoting publicly the reason, logic and science; i.e. biology. 

Why would any power hungry bourgeoisie elite promote biological truths? Without them, society will fall apart because the natural role of reproduction will no longer be considered useful and or correct. That is opposite to the narrative of the reprobate... "well, that may be but I don't feel like a father or a mother". The children from such reprobate couples, if there are any, will see that a lie is being perpetuated for selfish reasons and not logical biological ones. 

What would society look like if it were up to feeling reprobates, (a harsh but necessary colorful word which is in the dictionary)? I suppose the left would say according to Foucault, society would be free to imagine whatever it wanted to be. 

Right now, there are so many 'sexual' orientations or 'genders' out there that one could spend a lifetime trying to understand them. So, let's say that in a reprobate society where the bourgeoisie are excluded that one of those sexual orientations becomes more popular than another as society tries to reorder itself and it will. Couldn't you imagine that the one outside of the scheme popularity would 'feel' excluded or rejected or worse - made to feel like a reprobate by other reprobates?

Now couldn't you imagine in the social imagination, a war rising up among all reprobates who feel they are right to feel the way they do over any other ideal type of reprobate? Many will say no because all they really want is to feel like they do. Well, what if a human being wanted to feel and act like a dog? Why not? But, keep in mind, dogs are by nature pack animals. Or, better yet, make the argument that if you are a dog and I am a dog... I think or I 'feel' my instincts are better than yours. Now, that would be a dog's rationale if I were a dog... but I am not.

When rational thought runs out... you better look out! Thankfully, for now, stable society is yet working based on the natural 'biological' order of things in the social imagination. However, we seem to be at a tipping point.

Foucault seems to miss the main thrust of his own ideology... if the bourgeoisie can be in control of sexuality, why couldn't or why wouldn't the proletariat do the same? How could they 'the reprobate' be more moral or just/fair than the bourgeoisie of any society ever were? 

Is there any hope for the reprobate? Well, that's up to society at large in terms of what is stable. And, what again is that? Stable society is when there is consensus about what works (sustainably/stably) for the majority in the place where they are.


1 COR 15:38-39 ~ God gives it a body as He has designed, and to each kind of seed He gives its own body. Not all flesh is the same: Men have one kind of flesh, animals have another, birds another, and fish another.…


 




Wednesday, February 17, 2021

All in the Name of SCIENCE ~ Part II, in the Social Imagination...

What is science? According to online definitions: its an intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment. Science came from Old French, meaning knowledge, learning, application, and a corpus of human knowledge. 

As far as we know, Aristotle is considered by many to be the first scientist, although the term postdates him by more than two millennia. In Greece in the fourth century BC, he pioneered the techniques of logic, observation, inquiry and demonstration. Its not enough though for just one man to make a claim about anything and expect everyone else to recognize it is an absolute truth. 

Why? Because, we live in a state of entropy and though one man may think he has the truth, it can only be supported. Indeed, even Aristotle had to have social agreement among his fellow intellectuals. Otherwise, whatever his 'truth' was, it too was subject to entropy which every child who has ever played the game of telephone understands. Yes, we can conclude that even a group of people in agreement are still subject to entropy and all things people think and or make.

The social reality which exists only in the social imagination requires agreement in order that we live a life in what we can call ordered or not chaotic. Agreement comes through social dynamics of interaction between social actors and in that exists mistake because man is not an all knowing entity nor can he be. All the things, in this fallen world, its state of entropy, cannot be known to us in any absolute certainty... just read Werner Heisenberg's uncertainty principle.

The uncertainty principle states a fundamental property of quantum systems and is not a statement about the observational success of current technology. It must be emphasized that measurement does not mean only a process in which a physicist-observer takes part, but rather any interaction between classical and quantum objects regardless of any observer.

Strange isn't it that people use 'science' as some absolute truth as if it is outside of man's imagination and outside of entropy. There is no science other than what men agree it is. Just reread the definition above... its an intellectual activity. But, it cannot be accepted or appreciated as any kind of intellectual let alone practical activity until others agree on it. How does agreement come about? 

Does everyone see and think the same about what they see/hear/taste and smell? No, but people can be swayed, moved, lured, enticed, and coerced according to the laws of social dynamics which only takes place in social interaction... in the social imagination!

Science does not exist outside of man's imagination and it does not exists outside of man's agreement which by the way exists only in his imagination. Therefore, what man calls science is not an omnipotent entity outside of man or an equation waiting to be realized, recognized, admired, agreed on and glorified.

There can be only one absolute truth which is not subject to this world's state of entropy and that is God's Word! His Kingdom is within. Its contained within a vessel that is though subject to entropy...it does not and will succumb to this fallen world for He has overcome it! ~ John 16:33. I would rather be in agreement with God's Word rather than in agreement with man's vain imagination.

 

*SOURCES ~ All included texts/paragraphs or definitions are from online sources... do the research yourself. For more so called science visit this link: https://sciencehook.com/2019/02/04/10-science-experiments-that-went-horribly-wrong/