Contrary behavior means deliberately doing the opposite of
what others routinely or conventionally do.
The question is why do that? Is it a form of
deviant behavior? Is it a strategy to win favor for one's own agenda? Does it
serve a social purpose? Yes and no. Before, we answer those questions, let us
look at a society in which contrary behavior was a kind of 'norm' or served a
purpose for the society.
Contrary was a member of a Native North American tribal group who
adopted behavior that was deliberately the opposite of other tribal members.
The Contraries were found among the historical Amerindian tribes of the Great
Plains. They were a small number of individuals loosely organized into a cult that
was devoted to the practice of contrary behavior.
The Contraries are related, in
part, to the
clown organizations of
the Plains Indians, as well as to Plains military societies that contained
reverse
warriors. The Lakota word
heyoka,
which translates as clown or opposites, serves as a collective title for these
institutionalized forms of contrary behavior of the Plains Indians. When Lakota
Indians first saw European clowns, they identified them with their own term for
clowns,
heyoka.
The Contraries of the Plains
Indians were individuals committed to an extraordinary life-style in which they
did the opposite of what others normally do. They thus turned all social
conventions into their opposites. This behavior was not just tolerated but we
must imagine encouraged in some and not in others.
Maybe there were some who in the group/tribe who exhibited contrary behavior
(deviated from the norm) and it was encouraged as a means of sustainability
rather than to allow it to be destructive for the social group.
Especially, when we consider that the social role of the Plains Indian
clowns was ceremonial since they performed primarily during rituals, dances and
feasts. Unlike the clowns,
the special
role of the Contraries was not restricted to brief performances, rituals or
the warpath. It was their everyday life. The Contraries of the Plains Indians
were known to be not only unique but also historically unprecedented.
We can and should ask if we can observe this 'contrariness' in today's
post-modern Judeo-Christian Roman/Greek political society? And, if we can
observe it, why does it exist or is tolerated?
Aren't we here in the 21st century mostly
critical thinkers, free of religion? If yes, who would be contrary to that and
why? Likely, we leave that up to the psychologist or psyche-analyst.
Let's first consider what is critical
thinking, as the kind of thinking common among us.
The critical habit of
thought, if usual in society, will pervade all its mores, because it is a way
of taking up the problems of life. Men educated in it cannot be stampeded by
stump orators; hence they are slow to believe. They can hold things as possible or
probable in all degrees, without certainty and without pain. They can wait for
evidence and weigh evidence, uninfluenced by the emphasis or confidence with
which assertions are made on one side or the other. They can resist appeals to
their dearest prejudices and all kinds of cajolery. Education in the critical
faculty is the only education of which it can be truly said that it makes good
citizens. ~ William Graham Sumner 1906
We can probably agree
that critical society is a community of people who value critical thinking and
value those who practice it. It is a society continually improving and its most distinguishing feature or characteristic is its emphasis on thinking as the key
to the emancipation of the mind, to the creation of just practices, to the
preservation and development of the species.
Unfortunately there are no critical societies in the world. Nor have
there ever been. The idea represents an ideal not yet achieved, a
possibility not yet actualized. There is no culture on earth where
critical thought is characteristic of everyday personal and social life.
On the contrary, the world is filled with superficiality, prejudice, bias,
distortions, lies, deception, manipulation, short sightedness,
close-mindedness, righteousness, hypocrisy, on and on, in every culture in
every country throughout the world. These problems in thinking lead to
untold negative implications - fear, anxiety, sadness, hopelessness, pain,
suffering, injustices of every imaginable kind.
Perhaps, social media and news media, can be thought of as the
implementation of the contrarian social weapon. When you hear/read the news no
matter what your preferred source is... isn't it a kind of coping mechanism in
that you hope that whatever you hear and read is contrary to your feelings and
or opinions and this helps you to cope when they are and especially are not.
Perhaps, the Plains Indians Contrarians were used to combat: fear, anxiety, sadness, hopelessness, pain, suffering, and injustices
of every imaginable kind within their society. But, you should ask where is the agreement reality in that? Well, if you agree I can be contrary, and I agree you can be... there it is; I suppose. Maybe the purpose of being contrary is served in the vast landscape of the social imagination simply because 'critical thought' does not exist in the social imagination. And, thus everyone appears to be contrary. How could we be critical of the social imagination? Especially, in a fallen state as this social reality is since the Fall... exactly.
However, in agreement we can be and must be about only one thing - the Creator; and, in that there is no criticism. Among those who have such foundation, it is understood that people can agree only because there is an absolute point of departure (being) in the social imagination. Now, whether we agree on it or not does not matter as much as the fact that there is such even without having to agree. For sure, there are two different endings for those in that agreement reality and those who are not.
*Sources ~ Wikipedia [search Contrary]
https://www.criticalthinking.org/pages/critical-societies-thoughts-from-the-past/762